• Route planner
  • My activities
  • Blog
  • FAQ
Instagram Buy me a coffee
Connect with Strava
All posts

Why some roads look wrong on the map, and how you can fix them

12 November 2026

Also available in: Deutsch · Français · Nederlands

Every cycling route planner is only as good as the map underneath it. When a planner sends you down a road that turns out to be a dirt track, a private driveway or a busy main road, the reason is very often not the algorithm. It's the map data.

This post explains where that data comes from, why it's sometimes wrong, and how you can fix your own area in a few minutes.

Where the map comes from

RouteCycle, like many cycling apps, uses OpenStreetMap (OSM): a free map of the whole world, built by volunteers, a bit like Wikipedia for maps. Roads, paths, surfaces, cycle lanes, drinking water points and most sights come from there. Extra information about castles, monuments and other places comes from Wikidata.

OSM is amazing. In many places it's more detailed than any commercial map. But because it's built by people, its quality depends on how many people have mapped your area, and how carefully.

The typical problems

These are the issues I see most often in bad-route reports:

  • Missing surface. The most common one by far. Many roads have no surface tag, so there's no way to know from the map whether they're paved. In some countries, including the United States, most roads are missing it. I wrote a separate post about how RouteCycle deals with missing surface data.
  • Wrong road class. A busy road tagged as a minor one, or a quiet lane tagged as a main road. The class says a lot about traffic, so a wrong class leads to a wrong guess.
  • Missing or wrong access. A private road or a farm track that isn't open to the public, but isn't tagged as private.
  • Missing cycle infrastructure. A good separate cycle track next to a busy road that isn't on the map, so the planner sees only the busy road and avoids the whole corridor.
  • Old data. A road that was closed, rebuilt or resurfaced, but the map still shows it as it was.

When there are many gaps like these in one area, routes there get worse. When the area is well mapped, routes are usually good.

How to fix it yourself

You don't need any special skills. If you know a road well, you're the best person to fix it.

  1. Go to openstreetmap.org and create a free account.
  2. Zoom in to the road and click Edit. This opens the iD editor in your browser.
  3. Click the road. On the left you see its properties, called tags.
  4. Fix what's wrong. For example, set Surface to asphalt, gravel or compacted. Or change the road type, or mark it as private.
  5. Click Save, write a short comment like "added surface from local knowledge", and upload.

A few rules to keep in mind:

  • Only map what you know. Your own knowledge of the road, your photos, or what you saw when you rode it. Don't copy from commercial maps or their street photos; that isn't allowed in OSM.
  • Small edits are fine. Adding one surface tag to one road is a real contribution.
  • When unsure, leave a note instead of editing. Right-click the map on openstreetmap.org and add a note, and a local mapper will look at it.

Your edit appears on openstreetmap.org right away. RouteCycle picks up OSM changes on its next data update, so it shows up in routes some time after that. And it doesn't only help RouteCycle: every app that uses OSM benefits from it.

Or just tell me

If you don't want to edit the map, the other very useful thing is to send me the route. Every route in RouteCycle has a feedback button. A good report includes:

  • the link to the bad route,
  • a short note on what's wrong (busy road, private road, gravel, dangerous junction),
  • if you can, a link to a good route in the same area for comparison.

You can also right-click the map to copy the exact coordinates of the problem. I read every report, and they're how I find and fix the problems in the algorithm.

Try it on your own roads: open the route planner and see how well your area is mapped.

Read next

  • Gravel routing: most roads don't say what they're made of
  • How do you know a road is quiet? Where cycling traffic data comes from
  • Building a cycling route planner for the whole planet

Want a quiet ride from your door? Pick a start and a distance, and RouteCycle builds the loop.

Open the route planner
FAQBlogRoutesTerms & ConditionsPrivacy Policy